McLove
Love is an archaic notion,
says the repressed pragmatic within
the
girl whose wrecked, red heart still burns from the wounds of your words.
Why,
how could love
possibly
exist in a world
where
you can pick up your marriage vows as easily
as
you’d pick up a Big Mac
(I do, drive thru)
and
chuck those
sacred promises
out
your window & across the highway to blow and scatter like
barren,
disconsolate french fry cartons?
She’s
begun to think that love must have been battered
and
fried then stuffed into a 100% recyclable carton
and
sold with fries and a drink for $3.99
long
before she was in line.
People
will tell her not to give up, for perhaps
there
is still love to be found
in
rice cakes and cottage cheese,
but
it doesn’t matter-
she
hates rice and she’s lactose intolerant.
In my years upon this earth, I have had the privilege of
walking in a dozen different countries and sampling the travel experiences of a
lifetime—from exploring the exquisite details of Europe to lounging upon the
beaches of remote tropical islands, I have been one lucky, hopefully-not-too-ugly-American
abroad. But I can say without a hint of
pretense that continental road trips with my husband are among the highlights
of my explorative journeys of this globe.
He and I recently had the luxury of an eight+ hour drive to
our family vacation destination. Our
kids are at the delightfully distractible age where copious amounts of Spongebob
DVDs, unlimited Peanut M & M’s, and heaps of fuzzy blankets turn the back
half of the minivan (which, incidentally,
my husband so endearingly refers to as the “scrotum scruncher”—the joke lying
within the assumption that he feels emasculated to be seen perched within its
confines) into a fantastical fortress of pre-adolescent adventure, allowing
their father and I unadulterated chunks of time for chatting and catching up with
one another, reflecting on our escapades over the eighteen years we’ve shared
together.
If you know anything about my husband and I, you know that we are more
than polar-opposites—we don’t even originate from the same solar system. Him: Über-pragmatic-hard-headed-technologically-driven-conservative-fundamentalist. Me:
Utterly-over-emotional-free-thinking-head-in-the-clouds-liberal-artist. We’re kind of two bizarre halves of one
unholy whole—his chocolate is always in my peanut butter and without me, he’s
just macaroni with no cheese. (I’m hungry as I’m writing—please forgive the
gastronomical digressions.) Fortunately,
our studies in opposition have never failed to provide us with endless
subject matter for contradictions…er…discussions
in our lifetime together: each landmark upon the highway, a new point to
exchange perspectives—each song upon the radio, a veritable symposium for
survey and analysis.
In the sixteen+ roundtrip hours we recently spent together
upon the highways, we heard the new Katy Perry song “Wide Awake” exactly twenty
seven times. While I could enjoy taking
pot shots at contemporary music in general or top-40 radio play, I’ll avoid the
easy and the obvious and, instead, share how this particular song became the
grist for setting the mill of my memories to work. After over eighteen years together (barring a couple of brief breaks for
singlehood sanity) my husband and I are fortunate to have an honesty between
us that allows us to discuss the relative merits and disadvantages of our two
decades together rationally—and often entertainingly.
Don’t roll your eyes quite
yet—this is no tribute to connubial bliss or testament to the glory of married
life. Far be it for me to give anyone
else in this world advice—especially on how to better their lives…I mean, a
single candid glance at my life behind-the-scenes
would send the viewer clawing at his or her eyes, screaming for the sweet
sanctuary of their mothers. While I
believe whole-heartedly in serial-monogamy, I am no fan of the contractual nature
of marriage (just ask my husband about
the twelve years we spent together before being married—he’ll fill volumes for you
with my thoughts on the historical oppression of marital design.) However, having lived it, I do know a thing
or two about surviving the years with the person you fell in love with…even
when you don’t really recognize them—or yourself—any longer.
So, after hearing the song several times, I casually asked
my ordinarily dispassionate husband what he thought. Without hesitating, he quietly replied: “Men are assholes.”
This blew my mind. There was no self-pity, no opposite sex
recrimination—he simply believes that men are shit by their very nature. My first response was to chuckle—but the
horror slowly trickled in. He accepted
this as fact. How did he come to this
understanding? Have several millennia of
being the oppressive force standing on the wrong side of history brought about
the evolution of a cultured, neutered, homogenized hybrid of masculinity whose
knee-jerk reaction to being castigated (if not emotionally castrated) is to
mildly reply: “Yes, dear”???
You see, I think what began to gnaw at me was the complete exoneration that this lovely song “Wide
Awake” affords Ms. Perry and the thorough evisceration
that it awards Ms. Perry’s ex, my beloved Russell Brand. (Ahhh,
now you think that because I’ve exposed my bias, I cannot be fair—but I’ve been
a member of “Team: Girl” far longer than
I’ve been a fan of Mr. Brand—so, despite my proclivity to find him fabulous, I
do not find him without fault. Bear with
me.)
Women have come so
far in the past century—we are empowered in ways that our foremothers could
only have dreamed possible: we now
embody the majority of those seeking and achieving higher education, our career
opportunities are abundant (although we
still struggle to swallow the bitter pill of our failure to achieve economic
parity with our male counterparts), and our voices are growing stronger and
more recognizable with every leader we create, every obstacle we overcome.
Please don’t misunderstand me—we all need emblematic anthems
to buoy our spirits and rally our camaraderie in times of instability—but
instead of dancing upon the ashes of our past, why can’t we shoulder some
measure of responsibility for our own happiness (and the periodic causes of its loss)? Believe me—I get it. When I was a young girl, I bellowed “I Will
Survive”, “R-E-S-P-E-C-T”, and “Sisters are Doing it for Themselves”—and
championed a life without love after every single break-up because, in the
immortal words of Nazareth, “Love Hurts”. When we get hurt, we need something to blame
and what was once the source of our joy, is reallocated to the wellspring of
our pain.
This is all nothing new.
We each suffer heartbreak at the hands of someone at some time—the
industries of reality television, wine coolers, Fifty Shades of Grey publications, and Ryan Gosling’s film career depend
upon our torment to feed upon the emotional decomposition. Relationships have been falling apart since
Adam first blamed Eve for tying him up and shoving that apple down his protesting
throat, effectively bouncing them out of paradise. (That’s
how it all went down, right?) The
divorce rate in our country has hovered around the fifty/fifty mark for
decades—and predatory pundits rub their hands together in anticipatory glee at
the emerging reports that, post-recession, the billion-dollar divorce economy numbers
are predicted to boom.
These thoughts tumbled through my head upon the dozenth (not a word, but remember, I am a licensed
neologist) time Perry’s new ode to herself slipped through our speakers
before I really began pondering the lyrics.
Now, before you laugh about how shallow
the waters were that I was panning for philosophy, you should be aware of how
fiercely the kids of today ascribe to this kind of thinking. I cannot even count the times I’ve overheard the
brilliant, beautiful young ladies in conversations in my classrooms or seen
their status updates and tweets verbally gutting and filleting the boys in
their lives for being less than what they had expected of them—punishing them
publicly for being every bit of what they had always been: teenage boys.
Millions of young people look to Katy
Perry as an inspiration and a role model.
Her songs are omnipresent—but I would risk to venture that the themes
they are being championed for are troublesome.
While “Wide Awake” appears to be a glossy epic to regaining individual
identity after a harrowing incarceration, it sends a clear message: that the
only true, worthy love is one that is so powerful and all-consuming and
benevolent that it should never, ever hurt you or bruise you or make any
mistake of any kind.
That’s just bullshit, and it feeds the absolute wrong message to its
audience.
I will pause to confirm that this is not to speak for the countless innocents who are held captive in
hostile, abusive relationships—to them I give my tears, my empathy, and my
permission to burn the house down the next time the bastard lays a hand upon
you. But for any person who has spent a
single penny on a Chris Brown track in the last three years (you know who you are and you should be ashamed of yourselves) who coincidentally
belts out the lyrics to this Katy Perry song like a tattoo straight from their
hearts, I can only say: “What. The. Hell?” As an wizened member of this “air-your-dirty-laundry-publicly-for-everyone-to-read-and-see-and-hear-and-comment-upon”
twitter/facebook generation, I recognize that wagging my finger at such blatant
narcissism and selective memory is a waste of energy—but do we really need to
flood the airwaves with self-righteous odes that completely eliminate
complicity in the demise of a relationship?
Sure, Adele and Taylor Swift’s careers would come to an abrupt halt…but
what is the alternative? To continue
creating a soundtrack for the generation of blame-shifting, self-aggrandizing
young people we’re breeding? Eek.
Even Gotye had the balls to let Kimbra come aboard, giving
her side of their fictional fallout
and calling him out for his bullshit in “Somebody that I Used to Know”—the
nascent qualities that Katy Perry gives herself in “Wide Awake” and the
complete culpability she censures her real-life former husband with are
brutally misleading to her young fans.
It stirs a bitter bitchiness in me—and I can’t help but to wonder if she
had put half the time and attention into her marriage as she did her albums, videos, tours, promotions, and film—well…we might not be having this discussion at all.
None of us legitimately knows what goes on behind someone
else’s doors—we can only presume and postulate.
But Katy Perry and Russell Brand’s inalienable right to publicly discard
their marital commitment after little more than a year awakens a profound resentment
in me. Societally, we can’t seem to put aside our bigotry and agree that two
consenting adults who love one another should have the right to legally wed in
our country, regardless of sex or orientation—but these two can so quickly
dishonor the privilege that they never even had to lift a finger to earn? It’s appalling.
Oh, don’t get me wrong—I’m
not demonizing the little pop tart or her satyr-suitor, but they represent a
machine that as a young person, I would never have even recognized or acknowledged
and I wish someone had pointed out to me before I entered the harpy/crone phase
of my life. That we even look to
celebrities as role models or to be the architects of modern societal norms is patently
absurd—but the fact remains that they are the pulse in the beating heart of pop
culture. The troves of magazines, films,
albums, and merchandise we purchase prove our compulsions; we drink from their
veins, we feed from their waste, and—like it or not—they influence more of our
lives than we may [ever] be ready to
admit. We bring our precious children
into the world, nurture them, teach them right from wrong—then, somewhere along
the road, we step back and allow the cult of personality to determine the rest.
“But, it’s just so HARD!” the
young lovers cry.
“Love isn’t supposed to be this
difficult…” they sniffle.
Pssst. Hey kids, lemme let you in on a little secret:
YES, IT IS. Here are a few little nuggets of wisdom that
no one ever tells you and you’d be lucky to learn before you reach my ancient
age. I bequeath to you my four epistles,
certified authentic by my husband:
1)
Sometimes, when you most want to scream or throw
something or throw something while
screaming, the best thing to do is just
shut the hell up. Silence is a remarkable salve to the savaged
soul. Your brain continues firing off
the violent missives that you long to spew aloud, but you have the space and
the silence to edit and construct the clearest distillations of your feelings
instead of flying off hot-headed, slinging out verbal arrows that you can never
retrieve. (Just ask my husband—those suckers stay lodged and infect for years—I’ve got festering sores from 1994 still splintered in my head to pick
at on the slow nights…)
2)
Ingrain
the following into your brainà
not every affront to what you thought the
relationship was or should be is a reason to fall out of love. Not every series of affronts to what
you thought the relationship was or should be is a reason to fall out of love. If you are looking for a reason to get out
anyway (perhaps you are bored or you are
simply ready to find something new) then you don’t need to find some fault
of theirs to give you permission to go—just
open the door. If those are truly
the extent of your reasons, you’ll be doing them the favor.
3)
BELIEVE this—while the grass may be greener over
there, it has its own lawn shed full of insecurities, inhibitions, and a
cargo-hold full of its own baggage. Are
new relationships fun—is it refreshing to be dazzled by the tummy-butterflies
and stars-in-your-eyes antics of bourgeoning love? Absolutely. But you will eventually unlock the
metaphorical shed on the other side and, when you do, I can promise you that
what you find may make what you have now
look like Eden before the fall.
4)
If you
leave, you leave with you. You’ll wake up with you. You’ll fall asleep with you. Before you tip too many cocktails with your
friends or chug too many beers with your bros, regaling them with the horror
that was your previous relationship, remember: you’re the common denominator in all of your own messes. What are you doing to make yourself any better before the next new
beginning comes along…? Nothing? History repeats itself for a reason—you’ve
heard the clichés. Don’t doom yourself
to repeat your own mistakes.
Toward the end of her song, Katy warbles that she is “letting
go of illusion”—and you know what? THAT is a great message. Truly. But the thing is, you don’t have to let go of
a relationship simply because you grow up a bit. We should all let go of the expectations we
built about someone and love them for who they are…if we don’t, the love isn’t
unconditional… and if it isn’t unconditional,
what is the damn point? Frankly, I’m
simply scared for how this will add to the screwed up template that has been
created for the young people today. My
god—we are told to accept and love complicated, brooding, despondent men in
fiction—the Fitzwilliam Darcys, the Tyler Durdens, the Mr. Bigs, the Christian
Greys—but when the real men in our lives fail to measure up to the image issued to
us by Hollywood and marketing geniuses, we are disgusted, disappointed, and…disinterested??? The potent cocktail of mixed messages that
they serve us roofie our better judgment and feed upon our insecurities about
our bodies, our intelligence, our worthiness—and then we invert these fears and
wreck the real relationships in our lives for…WHAT??? The pattern is so dysfunctional
that it needs its own syndicated talk show.
Men have illusions and expectations, too, you know. They believe that the Victoria Secret
commercials do not lie and that it will be this way forever—and that you want it to be. (Any
young lady who wants to get inside their heads—even a wee fraction—should read Nick
Hornby’s hilarious and painfully honest “High Fidelity”—or you could always cheat and see the film, they’re both great.) Men are perpetually fifteen year old boys
inside their lovely heads. Watch any
Kevin Smith film and smoosh all the male characters into one and you’ve got the
idea. They think you will desire them as
much eighteen years from now as you did eight minutes ago. And heaven help them, they WILL want a trophy for their sympathy
for your cramps or picking up a box of tampons.
But, you see—just wait. You’ll get
your laughs when they’re there for your tonsillectomies or episiotomies or
lumpectomies—that is, if they’re even there
then. That’s my point. Whether you push them away or you leave, they
will not be there for you if you won’t let
them be there for you.
Hmmm…I think Epistle #1 needs a subsection, for
clarity. Be aware: sometimes the person you have loved and given yourself to
will not be enough. Sometimes they will fail you. Sometimes
they will make you cry and ache and wish
you had never even laid eyes upon them.
Sometimes they will make you
question every choice you have made since being with them. They will learn your buttons and they will push them when you least need them to—and
you will want to hurt them. Wound them.
Strike out for the things in your life that hurt you. So you will want to run, this is a given. But
know this—running away when it
gets hard is the EASY thing to do.
That’s the surest route to leave the pain of the past, right? Because these things will never come back to
haunt you, will they? Oh wait…
Katy wails that she’s “falling from cloud nine”—and this
absolutely needs to happen…you can’t walk beside someone if you’re on a damn
cloud. Put your feet on the ground,
bear down, and work your shit out.
Sometimes, no matter how much you put into something you love, you will fail—but will you honestly be
able to say that you gave it everything you had? If you can,
if the scars you bear script a roadmap of the routes in your struggle to stay
alive in a relationship, then you have earned
your right to a reprieve. Right this
way, next exit. But if not, sit the fuck down and study the
map again. TOGETHER. And pardon my
expletives, but if you have kids, man
the fuck up. Enough of this “right to personal happiness”-crack pipe
that every overindulged American has been sucking upon for the last couple of
decades. Give in before you get out—what
will it cost you? A little pride? A little time? A mere pittance.
Please trust me when I say that I know what I’m talking
about. The poem earlier was written by a
puerile nineteen year old girl who didn’t know shit about love (and still
needs a lifetime to learn, if we’re going to be discursive.) I was a calf fattened on a steady diet of
films like Say Anything, Pretty Woman, and Ghost, listening to Bono crooning to me in one ear that he can’t
live with or without me and Bret
Michaels caressing the other ear about every rose having its thorn—so is it any
wonder why I so willingly laid myself at “true” love’s altar like an ancient
vestal virgin? I didn’t want to be
someone’s “bitch” or to feign indifference to the “boys will be boys” antics of
the potential suitors out there—I wanted the pure, transcendental, magical love
of Lloyd Dobler (look it up if you must—but
really, you should know better).
Unfortunately, it didn’t hit me for about another decade that the
“magical love” guys weren’t that great either—didn’t Richard Gere originally
only want Julia Roberts because she rocked the slutty dress and the hooker-heeled,
thigh-high boots…and didn’t Patrick Swayze have to be dead for days before he could finally utter the
words to Demi Moore that he loved her? Hell,
even Bret Michaels took twenty five years of hard partying with bus-loads of syphilitic
strippers before he was finally ready to put a ring on the mother of his
children. Prince Charmings all around.
I was naïve, but in a way, triumphant. In our years together, my husband and I have
put each other through a lot—I do mean a lot, the details of which might
send the average tender-hearted youngster crying to the nearest monastery or convent,
disavowing the notion of “love” forever—but we are still here, better together
than apart. If we fail or do not make it
to the end of our journey together, we may rest assured that it will not be for
lack of effort.
Though she may balk at the kind of investment I’ve made in
my relationship, today’s young girl isn’t so terribly different—whether she
wants to admit it or not. She is
infinitely more sophisticated than the young ladies of my generation—and while
I am sad that she had to cut her teeth on role models like Britney Spears,
Lindsay Lohan, or sisters Kardashian, she was blessed to have had a Hermione
Granger, a Natalie Portman, and a Chelsea Clinton to look to for balance. Weaned from the bittersweet milk of her empowering
godmothers Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte, and Samantha, she may have had her
naïveté stripped from her early-on, but not her tenacity nor her confidence in
herself: she has been directed to embrace her superiority as a member of the
sisterhood. However, to be clear, while I
am thrilled that turnaround has
become fair play between the sexes—I do not believe that this self-entitled
hubris has done much (at least, so far)
for the young women of today—that is, other than to make them as irascible and
unyielding as their male counterparts have been for centuries. In fact, in a sense, she is even more torn
than before because she is constantly warring with the lack of limitations for
what society says she can be, what she wants to be, and how she wants to be
perceived. Unfortunately, these are rarely aligned.
From my observations, I sense that today’s young woman wants
to author her own sexual identity—a confusing and contemporary blend of virgin,
harlot, mother, or crone—but blanches at even the gentlest suggestion that she
cannot authentically be all these things at once. She resents being labeled, but the moment a
companion or love interest fails to meet whatever impossible archetypal amalgam
of Leonardo DiCaprio in “Titanic”, Ryan Gosling in “The Notebook”, or Rob
Pattinson in the “Twilight” films that she has been fed or constructed, she
feels betrayed—and likely has no idea why
she even feels this way.
I suppose this is an extreme oversimplification of human
needs—no two people want the exact same thing.
While some desire to be comforted and treasured, others want to be
challenged and dominated. Personally, I
hate games—I value honesty and directness, but the unfortunate fact is that love
is indeed a game and the rules are completely arbitrary. Now I think Epistle #4
needs an amended subsection: If you
don’t know who you are, what you believe in, or what you want to do in this world yourself,
how in the name of Aphrodite can you
expect another person to be able to
navigate the uncharted expectations inside YOUR
head successfully?
As the road trip relationship revelations continued, I focused
on the half-dozen or so people I know personally who carry songs like Katy
Perry’s as badges—as power ballad-token tributes to their unbearable
first-world problems of not being loved
enough or treasured enough or supported enough by the mates they
couldn’t bear to stand beside long
enough to earn their survival together. I know this sounds harsh—but there are truly
abused, truly heartbroken, truly empty and alone people out there…and to them I
say—I am so sorry. As for the rest of you, if you need a song
like this to empower you to get on to something or someone newer or hotter, I
hope you find what you seek—and I think you’ll deserve what you find. People’s affections are not used cars…you
don’t trade them in for better models with newer features. And you certainly can’t pay a mechanic to do
the work for you—you have to stick around and write the manual together.
In defense, I will say that the video for “Wide Awake” gets
one thing right: it is time for us, as a society, to collectively train our
daughters to abandon the antiquated idea that perfect men will arrive upon
their alabaster steeds to rescue them from their own lives. But while it is time to embrace the beauty of
independence and self-worth, we must be careful not to berate the opposite sex
or push the young people to live lives free of partnerships. That isn’t right either. Life’s journey is made better by
companionship—but we must seek partners who enrich our identities, not serve as
scapegoats for our own incomplete selves.
As for our two young daughters, half-unconscious in the back
seat, drenched in their respective chocolate and Spongebob fogs? I hope they find partners that make them
laugh and make them feel good about themselves…always. I hope they find
people who give to their lives more than they take, and make each
moment they share together better than the moments that came before. I hope they have confidence in themselves to
stand beside someone—but are unafraid to stand alone until that person comes
along. I hope they never think
themselves above or better than anyone else—but never accept ever being treated
as less than they deserve. I hope when
they commit themselves to something—a hobby, a career, a relationship—they will
see it through, even when it isn’t always as fun or as easy or as charming as
it once was. I hope they will have the
good judgment to know the difference between giving in and giving up. Finally, I hope they learn that life isn’t
supposed to be a party—it’s a trip. I
hope they stay the course and enjoy the ride.
Arriving safely at home, my husband and I wearily carry the
precious sleeping bodies of the children we created in the life we’ve made
together into our house—and I steal a quick glance at my travel companion. I’m wide awake, and you know what? The view is pretty damn good.